Pleasure Magazine

When Should You Replace Your Sex Toy? – No Worries, It’s Natural “Material Fatigue”

When Should You Replace Your Sex Toy?

When Should You Replace Your Sex Toy? – No Worries, It’s Natural “Material Fatigue”

Just like we don’t use the same toothbrush for 5 years, sex toys also reach a point where it’s simply a smart decision to replace them. This doesn’t mean what you bought years ago was “rubbish” – it’s just that the material, usage, and cleaning work together over time, and everything eventually wears out.

It Wasn’t Bad, It’s Just “Aging”

Most sex toys aren’t built to last forever. Even with quality pieces:

  • There’s natural material fatigue  constant bending, heat, moisture, and body fluids gradually change the material over time

  • The usage environment (humidity, temperature, storage methods) can speed up the process

  • If a toy worked perfectly for 2-3 years, that means you made a good choice  not that it was “bad from the start”

It’s like a good pair of shoes or a mattress: if you use it regularly, time simply takes its toll.

“I’ll Sort It Out, I’ve Got Plenty of Cleaning Products at Home!” – Well, Not Quite…

This is where things often go wrong. Many people think: “Why buy special toy cleaner when I’ve got toilet cleaner, kitchen disinfectant, alcohol, antibacterial spray something will do the job!”

Spoiler: it won’t. Long-term, you’re actually damaging your toys with these products.

Typical “I’ll sort it” mistakes:

  • “Let’s spray it with some good old alcohol, that’ll sterilise it”  Strong alcohol, disinfectant sprays, or kitchen cleaners will dry out, harden, and crack silicone or plastic over time.

  • “If baby bottles can go in the dishwasher, so can this” The dishwasher’s high temperature + detergent combo will destroy electronics, deform soft materials, and ruin surfaces.

  • “I’ll just wash it with something”  Strong hand soap, fragrant shower gel, or abrasive household cleaners? They’ll damage your toys just the same in the long run.

Specialist toy cleaners aren’t a luxury they’re pH-balanced and formulated to clean effectively without damaging the material. With metal or glass toys you might get away with home solutions, but with silicone, TPE, or other soft materials, this will definitely cause problems over time.

Why Is Replacement Recommended?

Not because “you bought something bad back then”, but because:

  • More porous materials (TPE, certain plastics, jelly materials) gradually absorb more moisture, lubricant, and bacteria

  • After lots of cleaning, lube, body fluids, and heat exposure, the material isn’t what it was when new

  • Even the smallest crack or micro-damage is enough for bacteria to settle in

So: it might still work, but at some point it’s simply a better decision not to risk it and switch to a new, modern, safer piece.

Signs It’s Time to Let Go

If you notice these, don’t think twice:

  • Sticky, oddly tacky surface

  • Changed colour or staining

  • Micro-cracks, small damage, surface scratches

  • Strange, strong smell that persists even after washing

At this point, the question isn’t “is it still good for something”, but whether it’s worth risking your health to save a few euro.

Why Upgrade?

The past few years have seen massive developments:

  • Better, more skin-friendly materials, modern silicones

  • Stronger, quieter motors, more functions, app control

  • More attractive, discreet designs, better ergonomics

Just like with toothbrushes: the old one was fine, but today there’s simply something better available. We’re not saying your old toy was bad – just that by now there might well be a safer, more comfortable, and more enjoyable alternative for you.

Browse Our Fresh Collection!

Choose by category and find your new favourite:

Don’t risk it – make the smart choice and refresh your intimate experiences!